The Determinant Dilemma: Why You Cannot Use RREF to Calculate a Matrix Determinant

An explanation of how row scaling and operations alter determinants, and how to calculate determinants correctly during matrix reduction.

How Row Operations Affect the Determinant

In linear algebra, the determinant of a square matrix is a single scalar that describes how the matrix scales volume. When performing row reduction, the three elementary row operations affect the determinant in very specific ways:

The RREF Trap

To reach RREF, we must scale every pivot row so that the pivot becomes exactly 1. For example, if a row starts with a leading entry of 5, we divide the entire row by 5 (scaling by 1/5). This operation changes the determinant of the matrix by a factor of 1/5.

By the time we reach the final RREF of an invertible matrix, the matrix has been reduced to the Identity matrix I. The determinant of the Identity matrix is always 1. Because we scaled away all the original numbers, we have lost the original determinant. If the matrix is singular, its RREF contains a row of zeros, and its determinant is 0. In either case, the original determinant is lost.

The Solution: Upper Triangular REF

To calculate the determinant using row reduction, you should stop at Row Echelon Form (REF), creating an upper triangular matrix, while keeping track of your operations. Here is the correct algorithm:

  1. Start with a determinant multiplier M = 1.
  2. Perform Gaussian elimination to reduce the matrix to upper triangular form.
  3. Each time you swap two rows, multiply M by -1.
  4. Each time you scale a row by k to make calculation easier, multiply M by 1/k (or keep track of it to divide at the end). *Tip: Try to avoid scaling rows by divisions if possible.*
  5. Once the matrix is upper triangular, the determinant is the product of the diagonal elements multiplied by M:

det(A) = M × (d11 × d22 × ... × dnn)

Go to RREF Calculator